An Eye For An Eye Witcher 3 Quest Guide And Choices
The secondary quest An Eye for an Eye in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt provides players with an engaging blend of tactical combat and meaningful moral decisions. Triggered after meeting with Vernon Roche during the main campaign, this mission tests Geralt's loyalty to his allies while impacting late-game narrative opportunities. Navigating this quest efficiently ensures that key characters remain alive to support you in future battles.
Starting the Quest and Meeting Vernon Roche
To initiate the quest, travel to the Temerian Partisan Hideout in Velen to speak with Vernon Roche. He informs Geralt that his second-in-command, Ves, has defied orders to launch a rash attack on Nilfgaardian forces in Mulbrydale. After discussing the situation, rendezvous with Roche near the Hanged Man's Tree signpost to prepare for the engagement.
Protecting Ves During the Skirmish
Upon arriving in Mulbrydale, an immediate combat sequence begins against the Nilfgaardian soldiers. The most crucial objective is to rush down to the village square and keep Ves alive throughout the fight. If Ves falls in combat, the mission ends in failure and prevents Roche from aiding Geralt later at Kaer Morhen.
Deciding the Fate of the Surviving Officer
Once the Nilfgaardian troops are defeated, Geralt and Roche discover a single surviving officer on the battlefield. Roche argues to show mercy and spare the captive to send a message to the empire, while Ves insists on executing him to protect local villagers. Players can choose either path without affecting the overall quest rewards or story progression, making it purely a roleplay choice.
Long-Term Consequences for the Main Campaign
Successfully completing this side quest secures Vernon Roche and Ves as allies for the battle at Kaer Morhen. Additionally, keeping them active is vital for unlocking subsequent political quests involving the fate of the Northern Realms. Players should ensure they complete this mission before reaching the point of no return at the Isle of Mists.